Insurance for Your Sports Card Collection
Your sports card collection is more than just cardboard. It’s your memories of big pulls, hours of hunting for that elusive rookie, the thrill of grading reveals, and the pride of showing off your cards to other collectors who share the same passion as you do! But high value collectibles like sports cards are a serious investment—and one that deserves the right protection from Private Collection Insurance.
Private Collection Insurance knows the excitement of hitting a redemption, the nerves of sending a grail card to PSA or Beckett, and the satisfaction of holding a pristine gem-mint in your hands. We also know the risks—damage in transit, theft, fire, water damage, or even just life’s unexpected accidents. We’re lifelong collectors too!
That’s why we’ve built insurance coverage designed specifically for collectors like you.
Why Homeowners/Business Insurance is Not Enough
Most homeowners’ insurance policies may only cover around $5,000 worth of collectibles, often with high deductibles, inadequate appraisal processes and exclusions. If you’ve been in the hobby long enough, you know that doesn’t even scratch the surface of your collection. A single card—graded or raw—can easily blow past that limit. And with only about 10% of collectors carrying proper coverage for their collections, most hobbyists are one accident away from losing everything.
With PCI, you get coverage that understands the hobby:
All Types of Cards Covered
Rookie cards, limited editions, autographs, graded slabs, full sets, or player PCs—we know what they mean to you, and we cover them all.Protection Against Real Risks
From theft and fire to accidental damage, your collection is protected whether it’s at home, in a safe, on display, or even in transit to a card show.Loss of Value Coverage
If a card gets damaged—even if it’s repaired or re-slabbed—we’ll help protect against the drop in value.Worldwide Coverage
Whether your cards are stored at home or you’re taking them to a show across the border, your collection is insured.Accurate Valuation
We’ve been in the hobby for years. We know grading scales, market trends, and how to properly assess the true worth of your collection.
Read our Latest Blog
Insurance for High-Value Items and Collectibles
Our team members bring a lifetime of passionate experience in collecting, which enriches our understanding of our clients’ unique needs and aspirations, especially when it comes to their prized possessions.
Private Collection Insurance (PCI) offers tailored insurance solutions designed to protect a wide range of rare and valuable items including, but not limited to Jewellery, Watches and Timepieces, Fine Art, Wine and Whiskey, Sports Cards, Comic Books, Memorabilia, Vinyl Records, Musical Instruments, Static Vehicle Collections, Coins, Firearms, Purses and Fashion, and other high-value memorabilia. We encourage you to click on the boxes below to learn more about our exclusive insurance for high-value collections.
JEWELLERY
Jewellery Insurance
Jewellery insurance protects valuable assets against theft, loss, or damage. High-value jewellery insurance offers essential protection for your most treasured items, including engagement rings, diamond bracelets, earrings, custom jewellery pieces, and cherished family heirlooms.
Learn more
SPORTS CARDS
Sports Card Insurance
Sports card insurance is ideal for card collections including rare cards, graded cards, autographed items, or game-used redemption cards. Our sports cards insurance policies may include replacement cost, coverage for display or storage, and protection during transport.
Learn more
WATCHES
Watch Insurance
Whether you own a single Rolex, heirloom timepiece or an extensive watch collection, our watch insurance covers theft, accidental damage, loss and more. Policies may include replacement cost, worldwide coverage, and protection during transit or display.
Learn more
FINE ART
Fine Art Insurance
Fine Art Insurance protects valuable art collections from theft, damage, and loss. We cover paintings, sculptures, and masterpieces and our policies may include replacement cost, transit protection, and specialized coverage for exhibitions or displays.
Learn more
MEMORABILIA
Memorabilia Insurance
Memorabilia could include rare and valuable collectible figures, historic artifacts, sports jerseys or commemorative pieces. Our memorabilia Insurance policies may include replacement cost, transit protection, and specialized coverage for exhibitions, private displays, or storage.
Coming Soon
WINE & WHISKEY
Rare Libation Insurance
Insurance for collections of fine wines, whiskey, spirits, and barrel-aged treasures. Whether stored in a cellar, displayed at home, or in transit, our wine and whiskey insurance policies provide comprehensive protection against theft and damage.
Learn more
VINYL RECORDS
Vinyl Collection Insurance
Insurance for vinyl record collections protects a cherished vinyl collection. Whether it's rare first pressings, colored variants, limited editions, or box sets, vinyl collection insurance ensures their treasures are protected.
Learn more
FIREARMS
Gun Insurance
Gun insurance offers protection for firearms collectors, covering theft, accidental damage, and liability. From rare firearms to sporting guns our policies may include replacement cost, transport protection, and liability for injuries or damages.
Learn more
MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS
Instrument Insurance
Musical instrument insurance protects treasured instruments, from classic guitars to grand pianos and rare violins, against theft, damage, or loss.
Learn more
STATIC VEHICLES
Vehicle Insurance
Static vehicles are showcased to preserve unique vehicles. Our vehicle collection insurance protects extensive collections, including exotic cars, motorcycles, and static vehicles from theft, damage, or loss. We also offer racetrack coverage.
Coming Soon
COINS & CURRENCY
Coin Collection Insurance
From antique to rare minted and commemorative coins we protect coin and currency collections from theft, damage, or loss.
Learn more
COMIC BOOKS
Comic Book Insurance
We protect rare, or limited edition comic book collections with our specialized comic book insurance against theft, damage, or loss. Whether stored, displayed, or in use, our policies ensure these valuable accessories are fully protected.
Learn more